- Updated on August 24, 2026
- IST 12:00 am
Three juries looked at the same year of Indian cinema. They could not agree on Best Film, Best Actor or Best Actress.
Nobody asked the people who bought the tickets.
The disagreement, laid out
Three juried ceremonies have already ruled on 2025’s Hindi films. Here is what they decided — after a note on the National Film Awards, which judged the year before.
72nd National Film Awards, announced 18 July 2026, covering films certified in 2024. Best Feature Film: Article 370. Best Actor: Kartik Aaryan (Chandu Champion) and Mammootty (Bramayugam), shared. Best Actress: Yami Gautam for Article 370.
Chetak Screen Awards, 5 April 2026. Best Film: Homebound. Best Actor: Ranveer Singh for Dhurandhar. Best Actress: Yami Gautam Dhar for Haq.
Zee Cine Awards, March 2026 (telecast 15 March). Best Film: Chhaava. Best Actor: Akshay Kumar for Kesari Chapter 2. Best Actress: Kriti Sanon for Tere Ishk Mein.
INCA Awards, 16 April 2026 (Hindi categories). Best Film: Chhaava. Best Actor: Ranveer Singh for Dhurandhar. Best Actress: Yami Gautam Dhar for Haq.
Two different Best Films. Two different Best Actors. Two different Best Actresses. Same year, same films, three rooms full of experts.
And the sharpest detail is inside a single ceremony. Zee Cine ran a separate Viewer’s Choice category alongside its jury awards — and it produced different winners from its own jury. Vicky Kaushal for Chhaava. Aneet Padda for Saiyaara. One night, one set of films, two verdicts, from the same organisation.
That is the whole thesis, delivered by an awards show that did not intend to make the argument.

What this does and does not prove
It does not prove the juries were wrong. Three thoughtful groups can weigh the same year differently and all be defensible. Homebound and Chhaava are not obviously comparable films and there is no arithmetic that settles between them.
What it does prove is narrower and more useful: there is no such thing as expert consensus here. When an award is described as the verdict of people who know, this is what that verdict looks like in practice — a spread, not a point. The confidence in the phrasing is not matched by agreement in the results.
Once you accept that, the question changes. It stops being “which method finds the right answer” and becomes “which method is honest about what it is measuring.” A jury measures the opinion of that jury. It just isn’t usually described that way.

The performance the country could not agree on
Ranveer Singh in Dhurandhar 2 has been one of the most-discussed performances of 2026, and one of the most divided. Gulf News’s review said he is “presented as a hyper-macho figure” and that the second half “plays out as an ode to Ranveer Singh.” The film sits at 36 per cent with critics on Rotten Tomatoes and 95 per cent with audiences — and it has passed Baahubali 2 to become the second-highest-grossing Indian film worldwide, behind Dangal.
Critics and ticket-buyers were not looking at the same object.
The cleanest split of the year, though, is critic against critic. On Mardaani 3, The Week’s review said the film “elevates itself beyond genre trappings”; Variety India’s called it “too little, too late as far as crime dramas go.”
Same film. Same week. Two national publications.

Even the numbers are contested
You might expect the box office at least to be objective. It isn’t.
Trackers such as Sacnilk, Koimoi and Pinkvilla regularly report different India net figures for the same film, and they do not always agree on whether a film has made money.
We are saying this against our own interest, because we quote those trackers too, and we will keep quoting them — while naming which one, every time. There is no unimpeachable number in Indian entertainment. There are sources with different methods, and the honest thing is to say so rather than to launder an estimate into a fact.

What IFTA does differently
Not a better jury. No jury.
India suggests the nominees. Every name is verified against independent third-party sources. India votes, one OTP-verified vote per person per category. And then — the part that matters most — the vote counts are published alongside the winners.
From IFTA 2022: Shershaah won Most Popular Bollywood Film on 5,201 votes. Sidharth Malhotra took Lead Actor on 3,744. Rohit Shetty took Director on 1,760. Mayank Arora, a supporting actor in a daily soap, drew 3,969 — more than twice the director’s count.
You may disagree with every one of those outcomes. You cannot claim not to know how they were reached. Few Indian awards show their arithmetic.
The year is still open
Since this piece first ran, IIFA has announced its 2026 winners without a ceremony: Best Picture to Dhurandhar, Best Actor to Ranveer Singh, and Best Actress to Aneet Padda for Saiyaara — the same actress Zee Cine’s viewers picked.
Which means the argument is still live. Three juries have spoken and disagreed with each other. And the only group nobody has consulted is the one that paid for all of it.
IFTA 2026 voting has closed and the results are in. No jury, no award fixing — every winner was decided by India’s votes. See the results: Bollywood · OTT · Television
Award results as announced by the respective ceremonies and reported by Hollywood Reporter India, Outlook India, Filmibeat, LatestLY, India TV and Khaleej Times. Box-office ranking as reported by The Week from Sacnilk figures.
Sources
- The Hollywood Reporter India: 72nd National Film Awards: Full Winners List; ‘Article 370,’ Mammootty, Kartik Aaryan and Yami Gautam Win Honours (2026-07-18)
- Outlook India: Screen Awards 2026 Full Winners List: Dhurandhar Leads With 14 Awards, Homebound Wins Best Film (2026-04-06)
- Filmibeat: Zee Cine Awards 2026 Full Winners List: Vicky Kaushal, Aneet Padda, Kriti Sanon & Others Win Big At ZCA (2026-03-15)
- India TV: Indian National Cine Academy Awards 2026 full winners list (2026-04-17)
- Gulf News (Manjusha Radhakrishnan): Dhurandhar 2 review: Ranveer Singh’s spy thriller struggles to recapture original blockbuster’s magic and mayhem (2026-03-23)
- The Week (Sacnilk figures) / Rotten Tomatoes: After a 46-day run, Dhurandhar: The Revenge registers its lowest drop yet; worldwide total nearing Rs 1,800 crore (RT page checked 4 Nov 2026: 36% critics, 95% audience) (2026-05-05)
- Khaleej Times: IIFA Awards 2026: Ranveer Singh, Aneet Padda bag top acting honours; ‘Dhurandhar’ dominates (2026-10-30)
- The Week / Variety India: ‘Mardaani 3’ review: Rani Mukherjee’s crime thriller elevates itself beyond genre trappings; ‘Mardaani 3’ Review: Rani Mukerji starrer is too little, too late as far as crime dramas go (2026-01-30)
You May Like This
You May Like This




















